Delay-Tolerant Networking E. Birrane
Internet-Draft Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory
Intended status: Experimental August 20, 2015
Expires: February 21, 2016

Asynchronous Management Protocol Agent Application Data Model
draft-birrane-dtn-adm-agent-00

Abstract

This document describes an Application Data Model (ADM) for an Asynchronous Management Protocol (AMP) Agent. The AMP Agent represents a managed device in the Asynchronous Management Architecture. This ADM identifies the Primitive Values, Computed values, Reports, Controls, Macros, Literals, Operators, and meta-data associated with an Agent. The information outlined in this document MUST be supported by any software claiming to act as a managed device within the AMP.

Status of This Memo

This Internet-Draft is submitted in full conformance with the provisions of BCP 78 and BCP 79.

Internet-Drafts are working documents of the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF). Note that other groups may also distribute working documents as Internet-Drafts. The list of current Internet-Drafts is at http://datatracker.ietf.org/drafts/current/.

Internet-Drafts are draft documents valid for a maximum of six months and may be updated, replaced, or obsoleted by other documents at any time. It is inappropriate to use Internet-Drafts as reference material or to cite them other than as "work in progress."

This Internet-Draft will expire on February 21, 2016.

Copyright Notice

Copyright (c) 2015 IETF Trust and the persons identified as the document authors. All rights reserved.

This document is subject to BCP 78 and the IETF Trust's Legal Provisions Relating to IETF Documents (http://trustee.ietf.org/license-info) in effect on the date of publication of this document. Please review these documents carefully, as they describe your rights and restrictions with respect to this document. Code Components extracted from this document must include Simplified BSD License text as described in Section 4.e of the Trust Legal Provisions and are provided without warranty as described in the Simplified BSD License.


Table of Contents

1. Introduction

An Application Data Model (ADM) provides a guaranteed interface for the management of an application or protocol over the Asynchronous Management Protocol [AMP] that is independent of the nuances of its software implementation. In this respect, the ADM is conceptually similar to the Managed Information Base (MIB) used by SNMP, but contains additional information relating to command opcodes and more expressive syntax for automated behavior.

Agents within the Asynchronous Management Architecture [AMA] represent applications running on managed devices that are responsible for implementing the AMA services of configuration, reporting, control, and administration.

1.1. Technical Notes

1.2. Scope

This ADM specifies the globally unique identifiers and descriptions for all Values, Controls, Literals, and Operators associated with an AMP Agent. Any implementation claiming compliance with an AMP Agent and communicating with an AMP Manager MUST be conformant with this specification. That is, it must compute all identified data, perform identified controls/operators, and understand identified literals/metadata.

1.3. Requirements Language

The key words "MUST", "MUST NOT", "REQUIRED", "SHALL", "SHALL NOT", "SHOULD", "SHOULD NOT", "RECOMMENDED", "MAY", and "OPTIONAL" in this document are to be interpreted as described in RFC 2119 [RFC2119].

2. OID Tree Identification

The Managed Identifiers (MIDs) used with this ADM encapsulate OIDs within a globally managed OID tree. The OID node from which all of the MIDs in this specification derive is called the "Agent ADM OID Root". This section identifies this root in the overall OID tree.

NOTE: This version of the Agent ADM uses a proxy Agent ADM Root that has NOT been assigned. The Agent ADM Root in this version of the document is only used for experimental purposes and MAY change before the final release of this specification.

OID Tree Identification
Agent ADM OID ROOT STRING iso.identified-organization.dod.internet. mgmt.amp.agent
Agent ADM ROOT ID STRING 1.3.6.1.2.3.3
Agent ADM ROOT OID (octets) 2B 06 01 02 03 03

                  
                              AGENT ADM ROOT
                              (1.3.6.1.2.3.3)
                                    |
                                    |
   Meta-  Primitive  Computed       |
   Data     Data      Data    Rpts  |  Ctrls  Literals  Macros   Ops
    (.0)    (.1)      (.2)    (.3)  |  (.4)    (.5)      (.6)    (.7)
      +-------+---------+------+---------+------+----------+---------+
                  
               

Figure 1: Agent ADM OID Subtree

The subtree under the Agent ADM OID ROOT contains eight subbranches that capture metadata, Primitive Values, Computed Values, Reports, Controls, Literals, Macros, and Operators as illustrated in Figure 1.

2.1. Nicknames

The following managed nicknames are provided to generate compressed OIDs within the AMP. Compressed OIDs enable shortening of common subtrees into a single numerical identifier to avoid the significant repetition incumbent with using OIDs from a common subtree. The nicknames defined by this ADM are given in Table 1.

Agent ADM Nicknames
Unique ID Label OID as ASN.1 BER
0 Agent Metadata 0x2B060102030300
1 Agent Primitive Values 0x2B060102030301
2 Agent Computed Values 0x2B060102030302
3 Agent Reports 0x2B060102030303
4 Agent Controls 0x2B060102030304
5 Agent Literals 0x2B060102030305
6 Agent Macros 0x2B060102030306
7 Agent Operators 0x2B060102030307
8 Agent Root 0x2B0601020303

2.2. OID Shorthand

The components in this specification are identified by their AMP MID value. However, for easier traceability back to the OIDs encapsulated in MIDs, an OID string is also provided for each component. These OID strings are provided in a shorthand that makes use of the nicknames defined in Table 1 and uses the form [nickname].relative-oid.

For example, the OID String [4].3.2.1 corresponds to the OID 2B060102030304030201, with 2B060102030304 being the expansion of nickname 04 and 030201 being the relative OID.

3. Metadata Definitions

ADM metadata consists of the items necessary to uniquely identify the ADM to Managers within the AMA. This includes items such as the name of the ADM, its version, and any nicknames used within the ADM.

AMP Agent Metadata
Name MID (Hex) OID (Str) Description Type Value
Label 0x80000100 [0].0 The human-readable ADM name. STR AMP Agent ADM
Version 0x80000101 [0].1 The ADM version. STR v0.1

4. Primitive Values

Primitive Value definitions represent those values that MUST be collected by the AMP Agent. Changing or updating Primitive Value definitions requires making changes to the AMP Agent application and/ or its supporting firmware.

AMP Agent Primitive Values
Name MID OID Description Type
Num Reports 0x80010100 [1].0 # Reports known to the Agent. UINT
Sent Reports 0x80010101 [1].1 # Reports sent by this Agent since last reset. UINT
Num TRL 0x80010102 [1].2 # Time-Based Rules (TRLs) running on the Agent. UINT
Run TRL 0x80010103 [1].3 # Time-Based Rules (TRLs) run by the Agent since last reset. UINT
Num SRL 0x80010104 [1].4 # State-Based Rules (SRLs) running on the Agent. UINT
Run SRL 0x80010105 [1].5 # State-Based Rules (SRLs) run by the Agent since last reset. UINT
Num Lit 0x80010106 [1].6 # Literal definitions known to the Agent. UINT
Num Computed 0x80010107 [1].7 # Computed Values known to the Agent. UINT
Num Macros 0x80010108 [1].8 # Macro definitions configured on the Agent. UINT
Run Macros 0x80010109 [1].9 # Macros run by the Agent since the last reset. UINT
Num Controls 0x8001010A [1].A # Controls known by the Agent. UINT
Run Controls 0x8001010B [1].B # Controls run by the Agent since the last reset. UINT

5. Computed Values

Computed Value definitions are expressions used to calculate data values, on the fly, from a set of other Computed Value definitions, Primitive Value definitions, or Literals using any of the Operations known to the Agent.

The expressions that define a Computed Value item are represented by MID Collections (MCs), which are ordered listings of the MIDs representing the expression arranged in postfix notation.


Original Expression : NUM_TRL + NUM_SRL
Postfix Expression  : NUM_TRL NUM_SRL +
Convert to MIDs     : 0x80010102 0x80010104 0x83070100
Resultant MC        : 0x03 80010102 80010104 83070100     
               

For example, the expression "# TRL Rules Defined" + "# SRL Rules Defined" would be represented as follows:

 
+----------+------------+-------+----------------------------+------+
|   Name   |    MID     |  OID  |        Description         | Type |
+----------+------------+-------+----------------------------+------+
|   Num    | 0x84020100 | [2].0 |  # Rules know to the Agent | UINT |
|   Rules  |            |       |      (# TRL + # SRL).      |      |
+----------+------------+-------+----------------------------+------+
|                            Definition                             |
+-------------------------------------------------------------------+ 
| 0x03 0x80010102 0x80010104 0x83070100                             |
+-------------------------------------------------------------------+                            
               

AMP Agent Computed Values

6. Reports

A Report is a listing of data items including Primitive Value definitions, Computed Value definitions, and other Reports returned from an AMP Agent. Similar to Computed Values, Report definitions are captured as a MID Collection (MC), which is the ordered set of MIDs identifying individual data items that comprise the report.

 
+----------+------------+-------+----------------------------+------+
|   Name   |    MID     |  OID  |        Description         | Type |
+----------+------------+-------+----------------------------+------+
|  Full    | 0x88030100 | [3].0 |  All known Meta-Data,      | RPT  |
|  Report  |            |       |  Primitive, and Computed   |      |
|          |            |       |  Values on the Agent.      |      |                  
+----------+------------+-------+----------------------------+------+
|                            Definition                             |
+-------------------------------------------------------------------+ 
| 0x0F 0x80000100 0x80000101 0x80010100 0x80010101 0x80010102       |
|      0x80010103 0x80010104 0x80010105 0x80010106 0x80010107       |
|      0x80010108 0x80010109 0x8001010A 0x8001010B 0x84020100       |
+-------------------------------------------------------------------+                            
               

AMP Agent Reports

7. Controls

Controls represent well-known command opcodes that can be run by the Agent in response to direct requests by an AMP Manager, or in response to time- or state-based rules on the Agent itself.

Note: There is no concept of a user-defined Control in the AMP system. All Controls are well-documented in ADMs with specific definitions of their behavior.

Controls may be (and often are) parameterized. Parameters are captured as special extensions within the MID itself. In cases where a given control accepts parameters, the MID flag byte will note that the encapsulated OID represents a parameterized OID and the OID will be augmented with the parameters for a specific instance of the Control, as described in [AMP].

7.1. Summary

The Controls known to an AMP Agent are listed in Table 6.

AMP Agent Controls
Name MID OID # Prms Prms
ListADMs 0x81040100 [4].0 0
AddCompVal 0xC1040102 [4].2 3 MID Id, EXPR Definition, BYTE Type
DelCompVals 0xC1040103 [4].3 1 MC IDs
ListCompVals 0x81040104 [4].4 0
DescCompVals 0xC1040105 [4].5 1 MC IDs
AddRptDef 0xC1040106 [4].6 2 MID ID, MC RptDef
DelRptDef 0xC1040107 [4].7 1 MC IDs
ListRptDefs 0x81040108 [4].8 0
DescRptDefs 0xC1040109 [4].9 1 MC IDs
GenerateRpts 0xC104010A [4].A 2 MC IDs, DC RxMgrs
AddMacro 0xC104010B [4].B 3 STR Name, MID ID, MC Def
DelMacro 0xC104010C [4].C 1 MC IDs
ListMacros 0x8104010D [4].D 0
DescMacros 0xC104010E [4].E 1 MC IDs
AddTRL 0xC104010F [4].F 5 MID ID, TS Start, SDNV Period, SDNV Count, MC Action
DelTRL 0xC1040110 [4].10 1 MC IDs
ListTRLs 0x81040111 [4].11 0
DescTRLs 0xC1040112 [4].12 1 MC IDs
AddSRL 0xC10401013 [4].13 5 MID ID, TS Start, PRED State, SDNV COunt, MC Action
DelSRL 0xC1040114 [4].14 1 MC IDs
ListSRLs 0x81040115 [4].15 0
DescSRLs 0xC1040116 [4].16 1 MC IDs

7.2. Control Specification

7.2.1. Overview

This section lists the description, parameters, and reports generated for each Control specified in this ADM.

The "DESCRIPTION" section lists the functional requirements of the Control when run on an Agent.

The "PARAMETERS" section illustrates and describes the ordered set of data items provided to the Control, when run on the Agent. A parameterized Control is represented in the AMP by a MID encapsulating a parameterized OID. OID parameters are captured as a Data Collection (DC).
The DC capturing these parameters is elided for clarity, as the DC is only the container used to transmit the parameters between the Agent and Manager and not expected as input to the Control itself.

The "REPORTS GENERATED" section describes the format of any Reports sent from the Agent to a Manager as a result of running the Control. This section ONLY describes Reports that are specific to the Control. Cases where policy requires Agents to send summary Reports when Controls either run or fail to run due to error, are not considered in this section as they are not specific to any one Control. Any Control summary reports should be as described in [AMP].
Reports generated on an Agent by a Control will either be directly sent to the Manager executing the Control or otherwise batched and send with other Reports destined for the receiving Manager. This behavior will be based on the policy associated with the AMP Agent and is not specified in this ADM.

7.2.2. ADM Controls

7.2.2.1. ListADMs

   +--------+------------+     +------------+
   | # ADMs | ADM 1 Name | ... | ADM N Name |
   | [SDNV] |    [STR]   |     |    [STR]   |
   +--------+------------+     +------------+
                                 

Figure 2: ListADMs Report Format

DESCRIPTION

The ListADMs control causes the Agent to produce a Report detailing the name of each ADM supported by the Agent. When an ADM is listed in this Report, it means that the Agent claims full conformance with the components detailed in the listed ADM.
PARAMETERS

This control does not take any parameters.
REPORTS GENERATED

This control will generated a Report capturing the list of ADMs supported by this Agent. The format for this Report is illustrated in Figure 2.
# ADMs
The number of ADMs known to the agent.
ADM N Name
The human-readable string associated with the Nth ADM, captured as a NULL-terminated string.

7.2.3. Computed Value Controls

7.2.3.1. AddCompVal

   +--------+------------+--------+
   |  Id    | Definition |  Type  |
   | [MID]  |   [EXPR]   | [BYTE] |
   +--------+------------+--------+
                                 

Figure 3: AddCompVal Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The AddCompVal Control configures a new Computed Value definition on the Agent. The generated value should be read as
Type ID = Def
Upon successful receipt of the Computed Value definition, the Agent MUST store the definition and be able to calculate the value at some point in the future. This capability MUST exist even through a reset of the Agent application.
NOTE: It MUST be considered an error if the Id associated with the new Computed Value definition is already defined on the Agent with a different associated definition or type. It MUST NOT be considered an error if the Agent already has configured the exact same Computed Value when this message is received. Put another way, this Control should be considered idempotent.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 3 parameters used to identify and define the new Computed Value. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 3.
Id =
The MID value identifying the new Computed Value definition. This value may appear in future Computed Value definitions, Report definitions, or Expressions.
Definition =
The Expression used to calculate this Computed Value.
Type =
The data type of the Computed Value. Note, this data type may be used to "cast" the value to something other than what is implied by the Expression. For example, the Type of a Computed Value may be set to INT even if the defining Expression contains all floating-point values.
The Type designation MUST be a numeric type, as the defining Expression is a set of mathematical functions on numeric types.

REPORTS GENERATED

This Control generates no Reports.

7.2.3.2. DelCompVals

   +---------------+
   | Ids To Remove |
   |     [MC]      |
   +---------------+
                                 

Figure 4: DelCompVals Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The DelCompVals Control removes one or more Computed Value definitions from the Agent. Upon successful receipt and run of this Control, the Agent MUST NOT store the definition of any identified Computed Values and MUST NOT recognize these Computed Values in the future, to include evaluating Expressions already in existence on the Agent. An Agent MUST NOT remove a Computed Value that is defined by a supported ADM.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 1 parameter used to identify the set of Computed Values to be removed. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 4.
Ids To Remove =
The list of Computed Value identifiers to be removed from the Agent. NOTE: It MUST NOT be considered an error if a given Computed Value identifier is not found on the Agent.

REPORTS GENERATED

This Control generates no Reports.

7.2.3.3. ListCompVals

   +-----------------------+
   | Known Computed Values |
   |          [MC]         |
   +-----------------------+
                                 

Figure 5: ListCompVals Report Format

DESCRIPTION

The ListCompVals Control produces a listing of every Computed Value identifier (MID) known to the Agent. A Computed Value is "known" by the Agent if it is defined in an ADM supported by the Agent, or was configured on the Agent by a run of the AddCompVal Control.
PARAMETERS

This Control takes no parameters.
REPORTS GENERATED

This Control will generate a Report capturing the list of Computed Value identifiers supported by this Agent. The Report will be included in the next "Data Report" message sent by the Agent to the querying Manager. The format for this Report is illustrated in Figure 5.
Known Computed Values =
The list of Computed Value MIDs know by the Agent.

7.2.3.4. DescCompVals

   +-----------------+
   | Ids To Describe |
   |      [MC]       |
   +-----------------+
                                 

Figure 6: DescCompVals Parameters

                     +-------+
                     | Defs  |
                     | [TDC] |
                     +-------+
                        ||
                        ||
     __________________/  \____________________
    /                                          \                                                                                                               
      +--------+--------+--------+    +--------+
      | # Defs | Types  | Def 1  |... | Def N  |
      | [SDNV] | [BLOB] | [BLOB] |    | [BLOB] |
      +--------+--------+--------+    +--------+                             
                           ||              
                           ||
              ____________/  \_______________             
             /                               \
              +-------+--------+------------+
              |  ID   |  TYPE  | Definition |
              | [MID] | [BYTE] |   [EXPR]   |
              +-------+--------+------------+
                                    
                                 

Figure 7: DescCompVals Report Format

DESCRIPTION

The DescCompVals Control produces a detailed description of every Computed Value identifier (MID) known to the Agent. a detailed description of a Computed Value is the set of information used to configure the Computed Value on the Agent.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 1 parameter used to identify the set of Computed Values to be described. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 6.
Ids to Describe=
The list of Computed Value identifiers to be described by the Agent.

REPORTS GENERATED

This control will generate a Report capturing the description of each requested Computed Value as known by the receiving Agent. The format for this Report is illustrated in Figure 7.
Defs =
The Typed Data Collection holding the set of Computed Values being described, as a series of type DEF. The TDC structure is comprised of the # Defs, Types, and DEF structures, as discussed below.
# Defs =
The number of Computed Value definitions included in this TDC.
Types =
The set of BYTE values identifying the types of the items in the TDC. For this Control, each entry will be of type DEF.
Def N =
The DEF structure (serialized into a BLOB, describing the Nth Computed Value definition. Each DEF structure is comprised of the ID, TYPE, and Definition of the Computed Value.

7.2.4. Report Controls

7.2.4.1. AddRptDef

   +--------+------------+
   | Rpt Id | Definition |
   | [MID]  |    [MC]    |
   +--------+------------+
                                 

Figure 8: AddRptDef Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The AddRptDef Control configures a new Report definition on the Agent. A Report definition assigns a single MID value to represent an ordered collection of other MID values. This ordered collection may include Primitive Values, Computed Values, and other Reports.
Upon successful receipt of the Report definition, the Agent MUST store the definition and be able to produce this Report at some point in the future. This capability MUST exist even through a reset of the Agent application.
NOTE: It MUST be considered an error if the Id associated with the new Report definition is already defined on the Agent with a different associated definition or type. It MUST NOT be considered an error if the Agent already has configured the exact same Report when this message is received. Put another way, this Control should be considered idempotent.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 2 parameters used to identify and define the new Report. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 8.
Rpt Id =
The MID value identifying the new Report definition.
Definition =
The ordered collection of MID values to be included in the Report when it is generated. When this Report is generated by an Agent, the values of each MID in this MC is included in the report. However, the identifier for each item is NOT included in the Report.

REPORTS GENERATED

This Control generates no Reports.

7.2.4.2. DelRptDefs

   +---------------+
   | Ids To Remove |
   |     [MC]      |
   +---------------+
                                 

Figure 9: DelRptDefs Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The DelRptDefs Control removes one or more Report definitions from the Agent. Upon successful receipt and run of this Control, the Agent MUST NOT produce the removed Reports and MUST NOT recognize these Reports in the future, to include rule actions requesting that the removed Reports be generated. An Agent MUST NOT remove a Report that is defined by a supported ADM.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 1 parameter used to identify the set of Report definitions to be removed. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 9.
Ids =
The list of Report identifiers to be removed from the Agent. NOTE: It MUST NOT be considered an error if a given Report identifier is not found on the Agent.

REPORTS GENERATED

This control generates no Reports.

7.2.4.3. ListRptDefs

   +---------------+
   | Known Reports |
   |     [MC]      |
   +---------------+
                                 

Figure 10: ListRptDefs Report Format

DESCRIPTION

The ListRptDefs Control produces a listing of every Report identifier (MID) known to the Agent.
PARAMETERS

This Control takes no parameters.
REPORTS GENERATED

This Control will generate a Report capturing the list of Report identifiers supported by this Agent. The Report will be included in the next "Data Report" message sent by the Agent to the querying Manager. The format for this Report is illustrated in Figure 10.
Known Reports =
The list of Report MIDs known by the Agent.

7.2.4.4. DescRptDefs

   +-----------------+
   | Ids To Describe |
   |      [MC]       |
   +-----------------+
                                 

Figure 11: DescRptDefs Parameters

                     +-------+
                     | Defs  |
                     | [TDC] |
                     +-------+
                        ||
                        ||
     __________________/  \____________________
    /                                          \                                                                                                               
      +--------+--------+--------+    +--------+
      | # Defs | Types  | Def 1  |... | Def N  |
      | [SDNV] | [BLOB] | [BLOB] |    | [BLOB] |
      +--------+--------+--------+    +--------+                             
                           ||              
                           ||
              ____________/  \_______________             
             /                               \
              +-------+--------+------------+
              |  ID   |  TYPE  | Definition |
              | [MID] | [BYTE] |    [MC]    |
              +-------+--------+------------+
                                    
                                 

Figure 12: DescRptDefs Report Format

DESCRIPTION

The DescRptDefs Control produces a detailed description of every Report identifier (MID) known to the Agent.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 1 parameter used to identify the set of Reports to be described. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 11.
Ids to Describe =
The list of Report identifiers to be described by the Agent.

REPORTS GENERATED

This control will generate a Report capturing the description of each requested Report as known by the receiving Agent. The format for this Report is illustrated in Figure 12.
Defs =
The Typed Data Collection holding the set of Reports being described, as a series of type DEF. The TDC structure is comprised of the # Defs, Types, and DEF structures, as discussed below.
# Defs =
The number of Report definitions included in this TDC.
Types =
The set of BYTE values identifying the types of the items in the TDC. For this Control, each entry will be of type DEF.
Def N =
The DEF structure (serialized into a BLOB, describing the Nth Report definition. Each DEF structure is comprised of the ID, TYPE, and Definition of the Report. NOTE: The type of each Report definition is of type Report.

7.2.4.5. GenerateRpts

   +---------------------+---------------------+
   | Reports to Generate | Managers to Receive |
   |        [MC]         |        [DC]         |
   +---------------------+---------------------+
                                 

Figure 13: GenerateRpts Parameters

                         +----------+     +----------+
                         | Report 1 |     | Report N |
                         |   [RPT]  | ... |   [RPT]  |
                         +----------+     +----------+          
                              ||
                              ||
                    _________/  \________
                   /                     \                                                                                                               
                     +-------+---------+
                     |  ID   | Entries |
                     | [MID] |  [TDC]  |
                     +-------+---------+                                                               
                                 ||              
                                 ||
     ___________________________/  \__________________________________               
    /                                                                 \
      +-----------+-------------+---------+---------+     +---------+ 
      | # Entries | Entry Types | Entry 1 | Entry 2 |     | Entry N | 
      |  [SDNV]   | [BLOB]      | [BLOB]  |  [BLOB] | ... | [BLOB]  | 
      +-----------+-------------+---------+---------+     +---------+ 
                                    
                                 

Figure 14: GenerateRpts Report Format

DESCRIPTION

The GenerateRpts Control causes the Agent to produce one or more known Reports and send them to one or more Managers.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 2 parameters used to identify the set of Reports to be generated. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 13.
Reports to Generate =
The list of Reports that should be generated by the Agent.
Managers to Receive =
The list of URIs identifying the Managers that should receive the generated reports. Note: a DC of length 0 is allowed by this Control. When such a DC is provided, the generated Reports MUST be sent only to the Manager that sent the Control.

REPORTS GENERATED

This Control will generate a Report capturing the description of each requested Report as known by the receiving Agent. The format for this Report is illustrated in Figure 14.
Report N =
The Nth Report generated by this Control. Each Report consists of an ID and Entries, as described below.
ID= =
The identifier of the Report. This identifier MUST be matched to a known Report definition with the same identifier on the Manager so as to be able to decode the contents of the report.
Entries =
The TDC capturing the series of data items that comprise this Report. Each Entry is a tuple of entry type and entry binary data.

7.2.5. Macro Controls

7.2.5.1. AddMacroDef

   +------------+----------+----------+
   | Macro Name | Macro Id | Controls |
   |   [STR]    |  [MID]   |   [MC]   |
   +------------+----------+----------+
                                 

Figure 15: AddMacroDef Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The AddMacroDef Control configures a new Macro definition on the Agent. A Macro definition assigns a single MID value to represent an ordered collection of Controls to be run in sequence.
Upon successful receipt of the Macro definition, the Agent MUST store the definition and be able to run this Macro at some point in the future. This capability MUST exist even through a reset of the Agent application.
NOTE: It MUST be considered an error if the Id associated with the new Macro definition is already defined on the Agent with a different associated definition or type. It MUST NOT be considered an error if the Agent already has configured the exact same Macro when this message is received. Put another way, this Control should be considered idempotent.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 3 parameters used to identify and define the new Macro. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 15.
Macro Name =
The human-readable name of the Macro. Agents MAY choose to ignore this value.
Macro Id =
The MID value identifying the new Macro definition.
Controls =
The ordered collection of Controls to be run when the Macro is run. The Controls that define the Macro must include parameters in their MID identification when added to the Macro. This ADM provides no capability to add parameters to the Controls of a Macro after the Macro has been defined.

REPORTS GENERATED

This Control generates no Reports.

7.2.5.2. DelMacroDefs

   +---------------+
   | Ids To Remove |
   |     [MC]      |
   +---------------+
                                 

Figure 16: DelMacroDefs Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The DelMacroDefs Control removes one or more Macro definitions from the Agent. Upon successful receipt and run of this Control, the Agent MUST NOT run the removed Macros and MUST NOT recognize these Macros in the future, to include rule actions requesting that the removed Macros be run.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 1 parameter used to identify the set of Macro definitions to be removed. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 16.
Ids To Remove =
The list of Macros to be removed from the Agent. NOTE: It MUST NOT be considered an error if a given Macro identifier is not found on the Agent.

REPORTS GENERATED

This Control generates no Reports.

7.2.5.3. ListMacroDefs

   +--------------+
   | Known Macros |
   |     [MC]     |
   +--------------+
                                 

Figure 17: ListMacroDefs Report Format

DESCRIPTION

The ListMacroDefs Control produces a listing of every Macro identifier (MID) known to the Agent.
PARAMETERS

This Control takes no parameters.
REPORTS GENERATED

This control will generate a Report capturing the list of Macro identifiers supported by this Agent. The format for this Report is illustrated in Figure 17.
Known Macros =
The list of Macro MIDs known by the Agent.

7.2.5.4. DescMacroDefs

   +-----------------+
   | Ids To Describe |
   |      [MC]       |
   +-----------------+
                                 

Figure 18: DescMacroDefs Parameters

                     +-------+
                     | Defs  |
                     | [TDC] |
                     +-------+
                        ||
                        ||
     __________________/  \____________________
    /                                          \                                                                                                               
      +--------+--------+--------+    +--------+
      | # Defs | Types  | Def 1  |... | Def N  |
      | [SDNV] | [BLOB] | [BLOB] |    | [BLOB] |
      +--------+--------+--------+    +--------+                             
                           ||              
                           ||
              ____________/  \_______________             
             /                               \
              +-------+--------+------------+
              |  ID   |  TYPE  | Definition |
              | [MID] | [BYTE] |    [MC]    |
              +-------+--------+------------+
                                    
                                 

Figure 19: DescMacroDefs Report Format

DESCRIPTION

The DescMacroDefs Control produces a detailed description of every Macro identifier (MID) known to the Agent.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 1 parameter used to identify the set of Macros to be described. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 18.
Ids to Describe =
The list of Macro identifiers to be described by the Agent.

REPORTS GENERATED

This Control will generate a Report capturing the description of each requested Macro as known by the receiving Agent. The format for this Report is illustrated in Figure 19.
Defs =
The Typed Data Collection holding the set of Macros being described, as a series of type DEF. The TDC structure is comprised of the # Defs, Types, and DEF structures, as discussed below.
# Defs =
The number of Macro descriptions included in this TDC.
Types =
The set of BYTE values identifying the types of the items in the TDC. For this Control, each entry will be of type DEF.
Def N =
The DEF structure (serialized into a BLOB, describing the Nth Macro definition. Each DEF structure is comprised of the ID, TYPE, and Definition of the Report. NOTE: The type of each Report definition is of type Macro.

7.2.6. TRL Controls

7.2.6.1. AddTimeRule

   +-------+-------+------------+--------+--------+
   |  Id   | Start | Period (s) | Count  | Action |
   | [MID] |  [TS] |   [SDNV]   | [SDNV] |  [MC]  |
   +-------+-------+------------+--------+--------+          

                                 

Figure 20: AddTimeRule Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The AddTimeRule Control configures a new Time-Based Rule (TRL) definition on the Agent. A TRL instructs the Agent to perform some Macro periodically over time, and to stop after so many runs of the Macro.
Upon successful receipt of the TRL definition, the Agent MUST store the definition and be able to run this TRL at some point in the future. This capability MUST exist even through a reset of the Agent application. Additionally, through a reset, the Agent must remember the number of runs of the Macro, even if the periodic evaluation of the rule is offset by the time taken by the reset.
NOTE: It MUST be considered an error if the Id associated with the new TRL definition is already defined on the Agent with a different associated definition. It MUST NOT be considered an error if the Agent already has configured the exact same TRL when this message is received. Put another way, this Control should be considered idempotent.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 5 parameters used to identify and define the new TRL. The parameters for this Control are illustrated in Figure 20.
ID=
The MID used to identify this TRL.
Start=
The time at which the rule should start to be evaluated. This timestamp may represent either a relative or absolute time.
Period=
The interval, measured in seconds, between runs of the associated rule action.
Count=
The number of times to run the action associated with the TRL, after which the TRL should be removed from the Agent. The special value of 0 indicates that the rule should be run indefinitely until it is removed by a DelTimeRules Control.
Action=
The Macro to be run on every run of the TRL, stored as a MC.

REPORTS GENERATED

This Control generates no Reports.

7.2.6.2. DelTimeRules

   +---------------+
   | Ids To Remove |
   |     [MC]      |
   +---------------+
                                 

Figure 21: DelTimeRules Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The DelTimeRules Control removes one or more TRL definitions from the Agent. Upon successful receipt and run of this Control, the Agent MUST NOT run the removed TRLs and MUST NOT recognize these TRLs in the future.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 1 parameter used to identify the set of TRL definitions to be removed. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 21.
Ids To Remove =
The list of TRLs to be removed from the Agent. NOTE: It MUST NOT be considered an error if a given TRL identifier is not found on the Agent.

REPORTS GENERATED

This Control generates no Reports.

7.2.6.3. ListTimeRules

   +------------+
   | Known TRLs |
   |   [MC]     |
   +------------+
                                 

Figure 22: ListTimeRules Report Format

DESCRIPTION

The ListTimeRules Control produces a listing of every TRL identifier (MID) known to the Agent.
PARAMETERS

This Control takes no parameters.
REPORTS GENERATED

This Control will generate a Report capturing the list of TRL MIDs supported by this Agent. The format for this Report is illustrated in Figure 22.
Known TRLs =
The list of TRL MIDs known by the Agent.

7.2.6.4. DescTimeRules

   +-----------------+
   | Ids To Describe |
   |      [MC]       |
   +-----------------+
                                 

Figure 23: DescTimeRules Parameters

                     +-------+
                     | TRLs  |
                     | [TDC] |
                     +-------+
                        ||
                        ||
     __________________/  \____________________
    /                                          \                                                                                                               
      +--------+--------+--------+    +--------+
      | # TRLs | Types  | TRL 1  |... | TRL N  |
      | [SDNV] | [BLOB] | [BLOB] |    | [BLOB] |
      +--------+--------+--------+    +--------+                             
                           ||              
                           ||
       ___________________/  \_____________________             
      /                                            \
       +-------+-------+--------+--------+--------+     
       |  ID   | Start | Period | Count  | Action | 
       | [MID] | [TS]  | [SDNV] | [SDNV] |  [MC]  |     
       +-------+-------+--------+--------+--------+ 
                                       
                                 

Figure 24: DescTimeRules Report Format

DESCRIPTION

The DescTimeRules Control produces a detailed description of every TRL identifier (MID) known to the Agent.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 1 parameter used to identify the set of TRLs to be described. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 23.
Ids to Describe =
The list of TRL identifiers to be described by the Agent.

REPORTS GENERATED

This control will generate a Report capturing the description of each requested TRL as known by the receiving Agent. The format for this Report is illustrated in Figure 24.
TRLs =
The Typed Data Collection holding the set of TRLs being described, as a series of type TRL. The TDC structure is comprised of the # TRLs, Types, and TRL structures, as discussed below.
# TRLs =
The number of TRL descriptions included in this TDC.
Types =
The set of BYTE values identifying the types of the items in the TDC. For this Control, each entry will be of type TRL.
TRL N =
The TRL structure (serialized into a BLOB, describing the Nth TRL definition. Each TRL structure is comprised of the ID, Start, Period, Count, and Action of the TRL. These are as defined in the AddTimeRule Control.

7.2.7. SRL Controls

7.2.7.1. AddStateRule

   +-------+-------+-----------+--------+--------+
   |  Id   | Start | Predicate | Count  | Action |
   | [MID] |  [TS] |  [PRED]   | [SDNV] |  [MC]  |
   +-------+-------+-----------+--------+--------+          

                                 

Figure 25: AddStateRule Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The AddStateRule Control configures a new State-Based Rule (SRL) definition on the Agent. A SRL instructs the Agent to run some Macro when a given Predicate evaluates to true, and to stop after so many Predicate evaluations. The Agent MUST evaluate the SRL Predicate every second.
Upon successful receipt of the SRL definition, the Agent MUST store the definition and be able to run this SRL at some point in the future. This capability MUST exist even through a reset of the Agent application. Additionally, through a reset, the Agent must remember the number of evaluations of the SRL predicate, even if the periodic evaluation of the rule is offset by the time taken by the reset.
NOTE: It MUST be considered an error if the Id associated with the new SRL definition is already defined on the Agent with a different associated definition. It MUST NOT be considered an error if the Agent already has configured the exact same SRL when this message is received. Put another way, this Control should be considered idempotent.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 5 parameters used to identify and define the new SRL. The parameters for this Control are illustrated in Figure 25.
Id =
The MID used to identify this SRL.
Start =
The time at which the rule should start to be evaluated. This timestamp may represent either a relative or absolute timestamp.
Predicate =
The numerical expression that MUST evaluate to true in order to run the action associated with this SRL.
Count =
The number of times to evaluate the predicate associated with the SRL, after which the SRL should be removed from the Agent. The special value of 0 indicates that the rule should be evaluated indefinitely until it is removed by a DelStateRules Control.
Action =
The Macro, stored as a MC, to be run when the SRL predicate evaluates to true.

REPORTS GENERATED

This Control generates no Reports.

7.2.7.2. DelStateRules

   +---------------+
   | Ids To Remove |
   |     [MC]      |
   +---------------+
                                 

Figure 26: DelStateRules Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The DelStateRules Control removes one or more SRL definitions from the Agent. Upon successful receipt and run of this Control, the Agent MUST NOT run the removed SRLs and MUST NOT recognize these SRLs in the future.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 1 parameter used to identify the set of SRL definitions to be removed. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 26.
Ids To Remove =
The list of SRLs to be removed from the Agent. NOTE: It MUST NOT be considered an error if a given SRL identifier is not found on the Agent.

REPORTS GENERATED

This Control generates no Reports.

7.2.7.3. ListStateRules

   +------------+
   | Known SRLs |
   |   [MC]     |
   +------------+
                                 

Figure 27: ListStateRules Report Format

DESCRIPTION

The ListStateRules Control produces a listing of every SRL identifier (MID) known to the Agent.
PARAMETERS

This Control takes no parameters.
REPORTS GENERATED

This control will generate a Report capturing the list of SRL MIDs supported by this Agent. The format for this Report is illustrated in Figure 27.
Known SRLs =
The list of SRL MIDs known by the Agent.

7.2.7.4. DescStateRules

   +-----------------+
   | Ids To Describe |
   |      [MC]       |
   +-----------------+
                                 

Figure 28: DescStateRules Parameters

                     +-------+
                     | SRLs  |
                     | [TDC] |
                     +-------+
                        ||
                        ||
     __________________/  \____________________
    /                                          \                                                                                                               
      +--------+--------+--------+    +--------+
      | # SRLs | Types  | SRL 1  |... | SRL N  |
      | [SDNV] | [BLOB] | [BLOB] |    | [BLOB] |
      +--------+--------+--------+    +--------+                             
                            ||              
                            ||
     ______________________/  \______________________             
    /                                                \
     +-------+-------+-----------+--------+--------+     
     |  ID   | Start | Predicate | Count  | Action | 
     | [MID] | [TS]  |  [PRED]   | [SDNV] |  [MC]  |     
     +-------+-------+-----------+--------+--------+ 
                                       
                                 

Figure 29: DescStateRules Report Format

DESCRIPTION

The DescStateRules Control produces a detailed description of every SRL identifier (MID) known to the Agent.
PARAMETERS

This Control accepts 1 parameter used to identify the set of SRLs to be described. The parameters for this control are illustrated in Figure 28.
Ids to Describe =
The list of SRL identifiers to be described by the Agent.

REPORTS GENERATED

This Control will generate a Report capturing the description of each requested SRL as known by the receiving Agent. The format for this Report is illustrated in Figure 29.
SRLs =
The Typed Data Collection holding the set of SRLs being described, as a series of type SRL. The TDC structure is comprised of the # SRLs, Types, and SRL structures, as discussed below.
# SRLs =
The number of SRL descriptions included in this TDC.
Types =
The set of BYTE values identifying the types of the items in the TDC. For this Control, each entry will be of type SRL.
SRL N =
The SRL structure (serialized into a BLOB, describing the Nth SRL definition. Each SRL structure is comprised of the ID, Start, Period, Count, and Action of the SRL. These are as defined in the AddStateRule Control.

8. Literals

This section describes the standard set of Literals available to all AMP Agents. Applications and protocols in other ADMs do not need to redefine these Literals, as they may be used in any expressions evaluated by any Agent.

AMP Agent Literals
Name MID (Hex) OID Value Type Params
AMP Epoch 82050100 [5].0 1348025776 UINT None
User VAST 82050101 [5].1 Varies INT VAST Value
User UVAST 82050102 [5].2 Varies UINT SDNV Value
User Float 82050103 [5].3 Varies REAL32 BLOB Value
User Double 82050104 [5].4 Varies REAL64 BLOB Value
User String 82050105 [5].5 Varies STR STR Value
User BLOB 82050106 [5].6 Varies BLOB BLOB Value

8.1. Configurable Literals Description

8.1.1. User VAST

+--------+
|  Value |
| [VAST] |
+--------+
                           

Figure 30: Operator User VAST Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The User VAST Literal is configured with information from a user in the system (via a Manager) to specify a specific signed Vast (64-bit Integer) for an AMP Agent.
PARAMETERS

The Literal accepts 1 parameters, as illustrated in Figure 30.
Value
The VAST being identified by this Literal.

8.1.2. User UVAST

+--------+
|  Value |
| [SDNV] |
+--------+
                           

Figure 31: Operator User UVAST Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The User VAST Literal is configured with information from a user in the system (via a Manager) to specify a specific unsigned Vast (64-bit Integer) for an AMP Agent. This Literal should be preferred for any guaranteed unsigned value in the AMP as it uses the SDNV format to more efficiently convey smaller unsigned values.
PARAMETERS

The Literal accepts 1 parameters, as illustrated in Figure 31.
Value
The UVAST, encoded as an SDNV, being identified by this Literal.

8.1.3. User Float

+--------+
| Value  |
| [BLOB] |
+--------+
                           

Figure 32: Operator User Float Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The User Float Literal is configured with information from a user in the system (via a Manager) to specify a specific 32-bit, Single Precision Floating Point Value stored in IEEE-754 format.
PARAMETERS

The Literal accepts 1 parameters, as illustrated in Figure 32.
Value=
The 32-bit floating point value in IEEE-754 format, serialized in network byte order.

8.1.4. User Double

+--------+
| Value  |
| [BLOB] |
+--------+
                           

Figure 33: Operator User Double Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The User Double Literal is configured with information from a user in the system (via a Manager) to specify a specific 64-bit, Double Precision Floating Point Value stored in IEEE-754 format.
PARAMETERS

The Literal accepts 1 parameters, as illustrated in Figure 33.
Value=
The 64-bit floating point value in IEEE-754 format, serialized in network byte order.

8.1.5. User String

+-------+
| Value |
| [STR] |
+-------+
                           

Figure 34: Operator User String Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The User String Literal is configured with information from a user in the system (via a Manager) to specify a specific NULL-terminated character string.
PARAMETERS

The Literal accepts 1 parameters, as illustrated in Figure 34.
Value=
The NULL-terminated string represented by this Literal.

8.1.6. User BLOB

+--------+
| Value  |
| [BLOB] |
+--------+
                           

Figure 35: Operator User BLOB Parameters

DESCRIPTION

The User BLOB Literal is configured with information from a user in the system (via a Manager) to specify a specific sized array of Bytes.
PARAMETERS

The Literal accepts 1 parameters, as illustrated in Figure 35.
Value=
The sized byte-array of the BLOB represented by this Literal.

9. Macros

Macro definitions are ordered collections of Controls that can be sequentially run. Each Control in a Macro MUST either be a non-parameterized Control, or a parameterized Control with parameters specified. There is no capability to add parameters to a Control after it has been encapsulated in a Macro.

The Controls that define a Macro item are represented by a MID Collection (MC).

 
+----------+------------+-------+----------------------------+
|   Name   |    MID     |  OID  |        Description         |
+----------+------------+-------+----------------------------+
|   User   | 0xC9060100 | [6].0 | List all user-defined data |
|   List   |            |       |                            |
+----------+------------+-------+----------------------------+
|                       Definition                           |
+------------------------------------------------------------+ 
| 0x04 0x81040104 0x8104010D 0x81040111 0x81040115           |
+------------------------------------------------------------+                            
               

AMP Agent Macro Definitions

10. Operators

This section describes the standard set of Operators available to all AMP Agents. Applications and protocols in other ADMs do not need to redefine these operators, as they may be used in any expressions evaluated by any Agent.

AMP Agent Atomic Data
Name MID OID Description # Operands
+ 0x83070100 [7].0 Addition 2
- 0x83070101 [7].1 Subtraction 2
* 0x83070102 [7].2 Multiplication 2
/ 0x83070103 [7].3 Division 2
% 0x83070104 [7].4 Modulo 2
^ 0x83070105 [7].5 Exponentiation 2
& 0x83070106 [7].6 Bitwise AND 2
| 0x83070107 [7].7 Bitwise OR 2
# 0x83070108 [7].8 Bitwise XOR 2
~ 0x83070109 [7].9 Bitwise NOT 1
&& 0x8307010A [7].A Logical AND 2
|| 0x8307010B [7].B Logical OR 2
! 0x8307010C [7].C Logical NOT 1
abs 0x8307010D [7].D Absolute Value 1
< 0x8307010E [7].E Less than 2
> 0x8307010F [7].F Greater than 2
<= 0x83070110 [7].10 Less than or equal to 2
>= 0x83070111 [7].11 Greater than or equal to 2
!= 0x83070112 [7].12 Not equal 2
== 0x83070113 [7].13 Equal to 2
<< 0x83070114 [7].14 Bitwise Left Shift 2
>> 0x83070115 [7].15 Bitwise Right Shift 2

11. Parameterization Examples

This section describes examples of parameterization within the AMP using examples from this ADM.

11.1. AddCompVal Definition

Consider the control "Add Computed Value Definition", which takes three parameters, given the following pseudo-code notation:

AddCompVal(MID new_id, EXPR def, BYTE type)

Where "new_id" is the MID of the newly created Computed Value definition, "def" is the Expression that is used to compute the value, and "type" is the enumeration of the resultant type of the value after it has been evaluated.

Consider that we would like to use this Control to define the Computed Value "# of Rules" from Table 4. The values for the parameters in this example would be as follows.

Parameter Type Value Description
new_id MID 0x9401040102 We assume that this is a compressed OID with an issuer field set to 1. All user-defined MIDs in the AMP are required to have an issuer field.
def EXPR 0x03 0x80010102 0x80010104 0x83070100 The expression (# TRL) + (# SRL) in postfix.
type BYTE 0x02 UINT

The MID for the AddCompVal Control is given in this ADM as a full, parameterized OID, which, from [AMP] is formatted as follows.

Expanded Parameterized OID Format

+--------+--------+--------+--------+
| Flags  | Issuer |   OID  |  Tag   |
| [BYTE] | [SDNV] |[VARIED]| [SDNV] | <=== MID 
|        | (opt)  |        | (opt)  |      Definition
+--------+--------+--------+--------+
                      ||
 ____________________/  \________________                                                                                     
/                                        \
 +----------+--------------+------------+
 | Nickname | Relative OID | Parameters |  <=== Compressed, 
 |  [SDNV]  |   [BLOB]     |    [DC]    |       Parameterized OID
 +----------+--------------+------------+       Definition
                                 ||
        ________________________/  \_________                                                                                     
       /                                     \
        +----------+--------+     +--------+
        | # Params | Parm 1 |     | Parm N |  <=== Parameter DC 
        |  [SDNV]  | [BLOB] | ... | [BLOB] |       Definition
        +----------+--------+     +--------+        
                                      ||           
                   __________________/  \______________                                                                                     
                  /                                    \                                            
                   +--------+---------+     +---------+
   Single    ===>  | Length | Octet 1 | ... | Octet N |
   Parameter       | [SDNV] | [BYTE]  |     |  [BYTE] | 
                   +--------+---------+     +---------+        
                  

Figure 36: Parameterized OID Format

  

 MID    Nick-                 
 Flag   Name     OID BLOB                      Parameters
+-----+------+-------------+-------------------------------------------------+
|     |      | Len  Octets |                                                 |
|     |      +----+--------+                                                 |                  
| C1  |  04  | 01 |   02   |030494010401020D038001010280010104830701000101   |
+-----+------+-------------+-------------------------------------------------+                                        
  

 Num                     
 Prms      Parm 1 BLOB              Parm 2 BLOB               Parm 3 BLOB
+-----+------------------+-------------------------------------------------+
|     | Len     Octets   | Len            Octets            | Len   Octets |
|     +-----+------------+-----+----------------------------+-----+--------+                  
| 03  | 05  | 9401040102 | 0D  | 03800101028001010483070100 |  01 |   01   |
+-----+-----+------------+-----+----------------------------+-----+--------+                                        
               

12. IANA Considerations

At this time, this protocol has no fields registered by IANA.

13. References

13.1. Informative References

[AMA] Birrane, E., "Asynchronous Management Architecture", Internet-Draft draft-birrane-dtn-ama-00, August 2015.
[I-D.irtf-dtnrg-dtnmp] Birrane, E. and V. Ramachandran, "Delay Tolerant Network Management Protocol", Internet-Draft draft-irtf-dtnrg-dtnmp-01, December 2014.

13.2. Normative References

[AMP] Birrane, E., "Asynchronous Management Protocol", Internet-Draft draft-birrane-dtn-amp-00, August 2015.
[RFC2119] Bradner, S., "Key words for use in RFCs to Indicate Requirement Levels", BCP 14, RFC 2119, DOI 10.17487/RFC2119, March 1997.
[RFC6256] Eddy, W. and E. Davies, "Using Self-Delimiting Numeric Values in Protocols", RFC 6256, DOI 10.17487/RFC6256, May 2011.

Author's Address

Edward J. Birrane Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory EMail: Edward.Birrane@jhuapl.edu